You haven’t heard ‘Royals’ until you've heard it done with a piano accordion, a Korean beatboxer and a Wellington soul diva. Or ‘Love Love Love’ by a bohemian bordello band. Or The Chills’ ‘Heavenly Pop Hit’ with the full choir it was clearly always meant to have.
Such is the work of the musical director – the key creative role in in the modern Silver Scrolls set-up. As the awards night has grown and evolved, the musical director has become responsible not only for fresh interpretations of the finalists’ songs, but the Hall of Fame tributes and the grand closing set-pieces. For, indeed, the look and feel of the whole show. (Shayne Carter is the musical director of the 2017 Silver Scroll, to be held in Dunedin on 28 September. He talked in advance of the event to Grant Smithies about the role.)
Mike Chunn did the job himself when he reinvented the awards in 1993, before handing it over to his former Split Enz bandmate Eddie Rayner, whose long run at the helm, until 2002, essentially defined the musical director’s role. And, says Chunn, kept the boss guessing.
“Being Eddie, he went crazy and he would bring in acts that sang the songs in different languages, all sorts of ethnicities, but it was great. It kept you on your toes.”
Victoria Kelly, who now works in member relations for APRA, took over from Rayner in 2003 and did the job until 2007, the last two years in partnership with Joost Langeveld.
“I loved every year I was involved,” says Kelly. “I think the key is finding a really interesting perspective on the original song, so you can reveal how that song remains a brilliant song and remains fundamentally intact regardless of who performs it or how it’s arranged.
“I think it’s fantastic to take a song and reveal unexpected aspects of it to people, and show how an idea can be interpreted in different ways, depending on who’s presenting it to you. And to see what remains when you do that, what can be kept from the original presentation.”
For Karl Steven (Supergroove, The Drab Doo-Riffs, Heart Attack Alley), musical director in 2010 and 2011, the most important thing was “really just having fun with it. And I guess unlikely pairings, both terms of song and performer and in terms of collaboration among performers.
“I come from a background where the audience is a very important part of the whole thing. So I was always trying to put on a show for the audience. If it’s a Sounz contemporary piece, a lot of the audience aren’t regular listeners to contemporary orchestral and academic composition, so I was trying to make it take a step towards them. Whereas with a straight-out pop song I’d try to take a step into an artier direction. So, engaging the brain, but not totally alienating people.”
In 2015, the 50th anniversary year, the musical directors were Godfrey De Grut and Cherie Mathieson. It’s effectively a repeat of 2013, where, despite De Grut nominally having sole charge, the two, partners in life as well as song, worked together on ideas.
“We each know how the other works, our strengths and weaknesses, and we vibe off each other. And we get to talk about it. Actually, all we do is talk about music,” says De Grut.
“Our kids tell us to shut up actually, most of the time, because dinner conversations always revolve around music or some show,” says Mathieson. “We live and breathe it.”
The pair had an inkling they’d be asked back when the awards returned to Auckland in 2015, so have effectively been planning for 15 months.
“You’ll be having a conversation about some song you heard on the radio and one of us will say ‘oh yes, that’d be a cool idea for the Scrolls!’ It’s been in our consciousness for such a long time,” says Mathieson.
“The thing about the Scrolls is our wildest ideas can be realised. We don't get as much pushback as we do on other events. We can kind of just go ‘I think we should insert crazy idea here’ and Ant Healey will say ‘yeah! I can see that!’”
No performance in 2013 was as oddball and as surprisingly effective as the interpretation of the winner, Lorde’s ‘Royals’:
“New Zealand’s a small country and along the road you just meet all these fascinating characters,” De Grut explains. “For many years, we’d known about this Lionel Reekie character who sang in RSAs with his accordion and was a wonderful performer. He was definitely out of the mainstream. Through our job judging competitions and awards, we knew of Philip Fan, a Korean boy who was an A-grade maths genius – a striking character all on his own – and did rapping and beatboxing on the side. And the trio was completed with our friend Bella [Kalolo]. Things come together in weird combinations.”
“Especially with a song as well known in that moment as ‘Royals’ was, it had to be different but still honour the song,” adds Mathieson.
Getting the ideas to the stage for the big night is not always straightforward.
“Musicians can be a bit like herding cats,” says Steven. “And particularly if you’re trying to find some unusual combinations and some acts that people haven't seen before, you get a very mixed bag. Some of them are extremely professional and eager, some of them are reluctant – and some have artistic temperaments, shall we say. And that can be a challenge.
“Also, trying to get a sense of what they’re going to do before they do it in front of everybody isn’t always that easy. That said, on the night everyone was great for the events that I did. But there were some stressful moments leading up to it.”
“The other interesting thing is that you cannot necessarily have control over exactly how they interpret the song,” says Kelly. “You have to be mindful of the fact that you’re asking creative people to give something of themselves to it – and you can't necessarily control that.”
And meanwhile, the finalists themselves sit at their tables on the night and hear their own songs they might never have imagined them.
“There’s nothing more amazing for a musician to have their music played back to them in a different way,” says De Grut. “To be covered is such an honour – and to have somebody spend time imagining and putting effort into how it might be re-contextualised is also a great thrill. It might not be the version of your song that you want to hear, but it’s a version somebody has spent a lot of time considering.”
Which isn’t to say it’s always an easy thing for the songwriters to hear.
“One year I organised for Gareth Farr, as Lilith in drag, to do ‘Fiji Baby’, and I think that Goodshirt were somewhat taken aback by that performance,” says Kelly.
“Bands occasionally find it quite challenging to have their work reinterpreted and it’s particularly interesting when you do it with the Sounz contemporary composers. Often their concept of their work is so very tied to the notes on the page and the instructions that they’ve given for those notes. There’s kind of sacredness to that work and it’s such an unfamiliar thing to have people come and reinterpret it. But the contemporary composers seem to love it.
“There’s just no telling which bands are going to love it and respond really positively and which bands are going to feel as if something’s been lost from their work with that process. But you can’t always trust the band to know how people are going to feel about it either.
“In a way, when you write a song and send it out into the world, you say goodbye to it and you have to let go of what people are going to attach to it in their individual ways, as it becomes part of their lives.”
Sometimes an interpretation will sharply divide even the audience. Lukasz Buda (The Phoenix Foundation), the 2014 director, underlined the event’s ability to embrace creative risks at which most others would baulk. He drafted in Wellington improv veteran Jeff Henderson, who recast Michael Norris’s ‘Inner Phases’, the winner of the Sounz Contemporary Award, as a squall of electronic noise, panning left and right across a darkened room. Some in the crowd responded by clapping their hands over their ears, but all the musical directors we talked to were enthusiastic about it as a standout moment.
“That was about as alienating on one level as you could get – and it was excellent because of that,” says Steven.
All the directors have their favourite interpretations, but the most emphatic about it is Kelly, whose crowning moment came right at the end of her five-year run.
“The only band I ever really, really wanted to get to perform was 8 Foot Sativa. Because I love death metal. And I had asked them every year if they wanted to do a song and they declined. And then finally, in the fifth year, they said yes. And so I asked them to do ‘Maybe’ by Opshop.
“Once they got the song, they really started to worry about getting up and doing it. And they pulled out. They rang up and said look, we’re really not comfortable about doing this, we feel like you’re taking the piss and we don't want to look like dicks.
“I was devastated and I went away and wrote them this enormous three-page letter that basically just poured out my love for them and said the one thing about APRA and our awards is that it’s not about the mainstream, it’s not about what’s popular, it’s about everything and everybody who’s making music, of all shapes, sizes colours and styles – and death metal belongs in there as much as anything else. And you guys are amazing and you’ll do an awesome version of this song and you should get up there and do it. And they changed their minds and did it!
“I was sitting at my table when they did it and I was so beside myself. I screamed until I had no voice left. I screamed so loudly that Helen Clark turned around and gave me the thumbs up!”
The Musical Directors
Steph Brown and Fen Ikner (LIPS) (2023)
Rob Ruha and Cilla Ruha (2022)
Rob Ruha and Cilla Ruha (2021)
Julia Deans (2020)
Nathan Haines (2019)
Bic Runga (2018)
Shayne Carter (2017)
Sean James Donnelly (2016)
Godfrey De Grut and Cherie Mathieson (2015)
Lukasz Buda (2014)
Godfrey De Grut (2013)
Jon Toogood (2012)
Karl Steven (2010 - 2011)
Don McGlashan (2008 - 2009)
Victoria Kelly and Joost Langeveld (2006 - 2007)
Victoria Kelly (2003 - 2005)
Eddie Rayner (1994 - 2002)
Mike Chunn (1993)